Protecting Individuals, Families And Children Every Step Of The Way

For More Than 20 Years
  1. Home
  2.  » 
  3. Child Custody
  4.  » Not always easy: court intervention re parenting decisions

Not always easy: court intervention re parenting decisions

Of course it’s a given that parents customarily wield sizable authority over their children and are given broad latitude regarding their determinations on matters focused on discipline, setting boundaries and the proper punishment — if any — to dole out when they believe doing so is in a child’s best interests.

That authority is not absolute, though, with government officials and courts sometimes stepping in to question it and, in select instances, forbid parental actions that they deem undermine rather than promote a child’s best interests.

Court involvement — often solicited in family law cases by one parent questioning the behavior of another — can spell a slippery slope when a judicial judgment is sought on parental prerogatives. For understandable reasons, judges are not always comfortable wading into the organic and highly personalized affairs of families, especially when they are asked to evaluate the reasonableness of disciplinary measures taken by a father or mother.

Yet sometimes they are flatly asked to do so, with their decisions having fundamentally important and even profound consequences for families.

A recent case from another state (yet with notable relevance in Massachusetts and elsewhere across the country) well confirms that point, with judges at two court levels engaging in an obvious struggle to seamlessly articulate and apply a standard for judicial involvement regarding one parent’s disciplinary action challenged by an ex-spouse sharing joint custody.

The gist of the case: A father shamed his 13-year-old daughter after catching her in a lie by making her post an embarrassing photo of herself online. Her mother objected to that strategy and took the matter to court.

Both a trial court and appellate tribunal opted not to issue an injunction n the matter, noting that the girl was not irreparably harmed by the father’s action, even if it was humiliating.

Words from the higher court’s ruling are telling, with the panel stating that, even though it was hard for the court “to imagine a more improper or inappropriate” punishment, it was “reluctant to interfere with a fit parent’s constitutional right to parent.”

How a court will respond to such a matter in any given case will vary, of course, with family law being a highly subjective realm.

Questions or concerns regarding any parenting or child-related matter can be addressed to a proven family law attorney.

Archives

5 Star Reviews

A Superb Lawyer!

Lisa guided me through the divorce process and helped me obtain my desired outcome. Throughout the entire process, she helped make the process as painless as possible. Lisa is truly a super lawyer who will be an asset to anyone that utilizes her knowledge, experience, dedication and abilities!

– Eric E.

Successfully Settled My Case With Just One Court Appearance

My ex husband is an attorney and I knew I needed a top notch attorney on my side in order to secure a favorable outcome. In less than a month, from start to finish, Attorney Ruggieri successfully settled my case with just one court appearance.

– Carol K.

All Of The Online Reviews Of Attorney Lisa Ruggieri Are True!

All of the online reviews of Attorney Lisa Ruggieri are true! If you need top-notch legal advice to land you on your feet post-divorce, I would highly recommend the Law Offices of Lisa Ruggieri. Lisa is very knowledgeable and draws a strong line around defending and protecting her clients.

– Eugenia Z.

She Was Aggressive And Never Backed Down

I found Lisa through reviews and was not disappointed. Lisa and her staff were great! They were very supportive and explained everything. She was aggressive and never backed down, even when I wanted to settle. She always looked out for my best interest, even when I didn’t want to. I can’t recall a single debate she lost during the entire case. If I were ever in a similar situation again (which will not be anytime in the foreseeable future!), I would call Lisa.

– Erik T.