Menu Contact
Law Offices of Lisa A. Ruggieri
Schedule A Consultation 781-489-3759

Fair property division in divorce: evaluating claim of "genius"

Massachusetts courts and those in most other American states employ a so-called "equitable property division" scheme when evaluating how marital property should be distributed in a divorce.

For myriad reasons (especially in a high-asset decoupling involving multiple types of property, e.g., realty holdings, family businesses, varied types of investment/saving accounts, company-sponsored benefits, art, heirlooms and so forth), that can get complex in a hurry.

So, too, can competing claims by divorcing parties regarding special talents or attributes they brought to a marriage that allegedly fueled its economic prosperity in a special way.

In one recent case that certainly qualifies as exceptional, a former spouse argued in a divorce appeal that a lower-court ruling on equitable property division should be adjusted (upwardly in his favor, unsurprisingly) owing to the proven dose of "genius" he brought to his marriage while it was intact.

That litigant, Randy Work, is a high-profile figure in the financial world who indisputably exercised singular talents and insights to drive profit for a global equities firm when he supervised one of its offices in past years. He says that such "special contributions" should have been judicially evaluated as genius in the first instance and entitled him to a larger than 50% split of assets totaling approximately $225 million.

Appellate judges in London disagreed, finding the claim to essentially be a slippery slope that they didn't want to venture anywhere near. They termed Work's "genius" appellation as "unhelpful" and instantly inappropriate in virtually all cases, stating that the designation properly applied only to figures such as Einstein and Mozart.

And while Work is undoubtedly a smart man, the court noted, his marital contributions did not entitle him to stand beside such historically lofty figures.

Work was "very successful," the court conceded, but success does not automatically equate with genius.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Contact Our Law Firm

To make an appointment, call 781-489-3759 or send an email to schedule an initial consultation. We serve clients throughout the Boston area. Our firm can take your call 24 hours a day and meet with you during business hours, evenings and weekends. For your convenience, we accept Visa and MasterCard.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy


27 Mica Lane, Suite 101
Wellesley, MA 02481

Phone: 781-489-3759
Phone: 781-239-8984
Fax: 781-239-8986
Wellesley Law Office Map

Law Offices of Lisa A. Ruggieri


781-489-3759 781-239-8986 - Fax